We have investigated different ways of bees’ stimulation to lay protein food while using artificial honeycombs. It has been proved that the use of artificial combs to get bee-bread upon the condition of the post-treatment processing of its elements by wax and honey syrup does not stimulate bees to lay and process protein food in their cells. It has been identified that upon the condition of the direct involvement of the working bees into the formation of bee-bread supplies the protein food has been mostly consumed. This proves that the working bees use the freshly-gathered pollen pellet for their own needs in the period of its active gathering. It has been determined that the most effective way of bee stimulation to reprocess pollen pellet into bee-bread is it's single densifying in artificial honeycombs with the follow-up processing of the upper layer of the feed by honey. This way encourages bees to form stocks of bee bread and decreases their activity of consuming protein food from cells of artificial honeycombs. The processing of thickened pollen pellet by honey probably oppresses the bees’ need to consume protein food from the packed cells redirecting them to other honeycombs of the bee family’s nest which has areas with bee-bread reserves.
Pollen is the only source of protein that bees collect from nature. This is very important for the development of the offspring, and thus for the development of bee colonies (
The next stage of pollen transport is the pollen being collected from the foraging bees to the hive and packed into honeycomb cells (
Pollen sheaths are dissolved just in the process of pollen transformation into the bee bread and in this form, it becomes more readily absorbed. Fermentation to the form of bee bread not only protects the pollen against the loss of properties but also gives rise to new components as a result of enzymatic transformations. The pollen proteins are degraded to peptides and amino acids during the fermentation process (
Proper hive management promotes the bee-bread collection, aimed at marketing it for human consumption since it can be considered as a food supplement due to its content of a wide range of nutrients. One of the contributions to their high nutritional value is the presence of significant amounts of proteins, flavonoids, vitamins, and phenolic compounds as natural antioxidants (
Results of other studies (
The bees use bee pollen pellets to store bee bread as a source of nutrition for the bee colony in the honeycomb cells formed. In experiments, we assumed that bees will also use artificial honeycombs for this process, to which a pollen pellet will also be supplied. Proof of the acceptance of artificial honeycombs by the bee colony will be the preparation of bee bread for its nutrition.
Taking into account the peculiarity of bees’ reaction to non-natural materials for them, we have to solve two problems, namely, encourage bees to domesticate the artificial honeycomb and make them concentrate protein feed in its cells (Figure
General view of artificial combs to get bee bread. Note: 1. Clamping 2. Artificial combs 3. Wooden block.
In other cases, the cells with honeycombs have been processed. In research group 1 the honeycombs have been processed by wax. To do this, the containers have been put into the melted wax for a few seconds, and then honeycombs have been formed out of them and have been put into the nests of bee colonies into the same areas of nests as in the test group. In the research group, 2 artificial honeycombs, except the ones that have been processed by wax, have been irrigated by honey syrup. Having installed honeycombs into the nests of bee colonies, the records have been done in the same way as in the test group (
The next type of reaction of bees on laying protein feed was encouraging them to concentrate on making bee bread pellets using attracting workers by putting pollen pellet directly into the cells of containers of the artificial honeycomb (Figure
General view of artificial combs to get bee bread (1), bee bread pellets derived from new technology (2).
General view of bee bread pellets obtained in a primitive way (A) and newly developed (B).
In research groups 3 – 6 during a daily inspection of artificial honeycombs and the record of cells filled with protein food they appeared to be empty (Figure
Placement of an artificial honeycomb with densely obstructed nets in the family.
The process of filling the cell freshly pollen basket.
For the characteristics of the files, we used the basic descriptors of variability: average, minimum measured value, maximum measured value, the coefficient of variation (%). Data were analyzed with ANOVA test and differences between means compared through the Tukey- Kramer test (α = 0.05). The degree of variability was determined by the coefficient of variation values. The given parameter is independent of the unit of the evaluated character.
To stimulate honey bee colonies to store up protein food, lots of work has been done to form their nests. In every group, we have chosen honeycombs from every bee family. These honeycombs contain lots of cells filled with bee bread. Taking into account the fact that bees mostly consume bee bread while feeding slugs, we have chosen one honeycomb with sealed brood out of the nests. Instead of them, we have put the ones with unsealed brood. The honeycombs with sealed brood have been moved into the nests of bee colonies of the user group. The frames with slugs for experimental bee colonies have been chosen from them as well. According to our plan, the protein food deficit and a great number of the unsealed brood had to stimulate the bees to activate the process of collecting pollen.
According to the results of undertaken studies, the following things have been determined and brought to light (Table
The effectiveness of putting the protein food by working bees under various conditions of preparation of artificial combs, n = 5.
The way of comb preparation | Domesticated cells among 5496 in the comb | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
The number of iterations | ||||||||
I | II | III | IV | |||||
M ±SD | % | M ±SD | % | M ±SD | % | M ±SD | % | |
|
||||||||
– | – | – | – | – | – | 0.2 ±0.2 | 0.004 | |
– | – | 0.2 ±0.20 | 0.004 | 0.8 ±0.58 | 0.015 | 0.2 ±0.20 | 0.004 | |
– | – | 1.2 ±0,58 | 0.022 | 1.4 ±0.60 * | 0.025 | 1.8 ±0.37 ** | 0.033 | |
0.4 ±0.24 | 0.007 | 2.2 ±0.58 ** | 0.400 | 4.4 ±0.93 *** | 0.080 | 10.8 ±2.15 ** | 0.197 | |
11.0 ±2.00 *** | 0.200 | 17.0 ±2.43 *** | 0.309 | 54.2 ±7.66 *** | 0.986 | 52.2 ±8.02 *** | 0.950 | |
24.0 ±3.61 *** | 0.437 | 100.0 ±4.64 **** | 1.820 | 194.6 ±25.76 *** | 3.540 | 239.2 ±24.36 **** | 4.352 | |
617.0 ±37.87 **** | 11.226 | 636.6 ±36.74 **** | 11.583 | 976.6 ±58.67 **** | 17.769 | 4492.6 ±362.02 **** | 81.743 |
Notes: I – 1st sampling; II – 2nd sampling; III – 3rd sampling; ІV – 4th sampling; mean – arithmetic mean; SD – standard error of the mean; *
The results that we got, having tested the artificial honeycomb in the test group, indicate that bees passively domesticate cells in the sections and it’s impossible to use the artificial honeycomb effectively without involving the additional stimulation.
The results of testing artificial honeycombs in bee colonies of research groups 1 and 2 haven’t been encouraging. During the first record in research group 1, in which honeycombs have been processed by wax, as well as in group 2, in which the cells have been processed by wax and honey syrup, the bees don´t have to involve either of the cells to store food. In a day (record 2) we have seen the presence of protein food in separate cells of artificial honeycombs of research bee colonies 1 and 2. During the next two records, the intensity of forming protein reserves in these groups was almost of the same level. The bees of these colonies have involved the additional space for laying pollen pellet, but it referred only to at least 10 cells which constituted 0.004 and 0.003% from their overall amount of the honeycomb. It was noticed that in the process of forming bee bread reserves the bees not only filled the cells of the honeycomb with pollen pellet but also took food out of them.
Thus, using the artificial combs for making bee bread, even with extra processing of its elements with wax and honey syrup, does not encourage bees to lay and process protein food in cells.
The research of the etiology of bees with the help of different methods of putting dry and freshly harvested bee pollen pellets has been very encouraging. We have used dried pollen pellet in researches 3 and 4.
As it appeared to be, the bees in the bee family in the 3rd research group passively reacted to fill the cells with pollen pellet. The percentage of the cells filled with bee bread, regarding their overall amount on the artificial honeycombs, was from 0.007 to 0.4%, on the condition that we refilled empty honeycombs with pollen pellet daily. Even when we processed pollen pellet with honey syrup (research 4) and thickened them, the bees insignificantly activated the process of laying the bee bread into the cells of artificial honeycombs. Using this method, we have identified a slight increase in the number of cells with bee bread located on artificial honeycombs – 0.2 – 1%. It is important to underline that the bees enlarged the space for bee bread in these honeycombs with every following fill-up of the empty cells with pollen pellet. If to compare these results with the test group, the activity of bee families of this group in laying protein food was much higher.
Thus, the use of dry pollen pellet on the condition that it’s put into the box of artificial honeycombs in small amounts doesn’t stimulate bees to lay the bee bread intensively, even if the thickening and the processing of the food by honey syrup are done 4 times.
A completely different reaction of bees on laying the bee bread reserves took place when freshly harvested pollen pellet was used. In research group 5 the bees enlarged the space for forming protein food reserves even though 3 – 5 pollen pellets were put into the cells of artificial honeycombs without being thickened. At the same time, if to look at the total amount of the cells of honeycombs in terms of quantity, these results would be still minor, but a sequence higher than in research 4 and other previous groups of bee colonies. For example, after the first fill-in of the fresh pollen pellet, the bees have put bee bread into the cells on the area that exceeded the research group 4 2.2 times. During the second record, the differences between these groups were 5.9 times, during the 3rd record – 3.6, the 4th – 4.6 times. If to compare it with the test group, the difference in data was highly probable (
The most encouraging results were received in the 6th research group. In this group after 3 – 5 pollen pellets have been put into the cells and thickened, the artificial honeycombs were moved to the nests of bee colonies so that they could form protein food reserves. The research showed that during the first record the bees started to prepare the reserves of bee bread in 11.2% of cells of their total amount in the honeycombs. Compared to research 5, the bees of this group have enlarged the space for reprocessing pollen pellet into bee bread in honeycombs by 25.7 times.
After the next filling of the empty cells, the bees of this group slowed down the pace of forming protein food reserves. The number of cells with bee bread after the second record has increased by 3.2%. During the 3rd record, the number of cells filled with bee bread in the artificial combs exceeded the area of section 4. After the cells have been filled with pollen pellet for the 4th time, the percentage of laying bee bread by workers was 81.7%.
Bees mainly laid the bee bread reserves starting from the bottom sections of the artificial honeycomb located closer to the back wall of the beehive. Besides that, the bees domesticated the cells and laid the bee bread better on those sides of the artificial honeycombs which were oriented to the central part of the nests of honey bee colonies, namely to the hive entrance block. The cells, which the bees laid bee bread into, could be identified according to several features. Examining the honeycombs in the cells, we found freshly harvested pollen pellet. The bees often dipped into them and the shiny spew appeared on the surface of protein food where the process of forming the pellets of the bee bread was finished.
In the process of forming protein food reserves, the bees managed not only to store bee bread but also consumed it even from those cells in which the upper layer of the pollen the bees processed by honey. However, the bees mostly consumed the protein food for the needs of their colonies from those cells which haven’t been filled up with pollen pellet completely. As a rule, the bees did not consume the bee bread from the central sections and they ate bee bread in small amounts from the peripheral zones.
So, the workers on the artificial honeycombs to store protein food actively start to domesticate those cells which contain the first portions of the thickened freshly harvested pollen pellet. Processing of the cells by wax or honey syrup doesn’t stimulate the bees to domesticate artificial honeycombs.
The sections of artificial honeycombs that were located closer to the back wall of the beehive were mostly the area for storing protein food. The bees gradually domesticate all the cells of the artificial honeycombs to process pollen pellet into bee bread. To make the bees lay and thicken pollen pellet it is necessary to fill the empty cells with freshly harvested pellets and thicken them not less than 4 times a day. It is not appropriate to use dried pollen pellet to stimulate the bees to lay bee bread into the cells of artificial honeycombs. The bees mostly take dried pellet out of the cells and unwillingly lay protein food reserves into them.
Taking into account that the most effective way of stimulating bees to store bee bread on the artificial honeycomb is the method of thickening of 3 – 5 pellets of freshly chosen pollen pellet in the cells, it was used in further researches. Besides that, we were interested in researching the question of bees’ reaction to protein food if 2/3rd of the cells were filled with freshly harvested pollen pellets.
While researching the ethnology of bees that laid protein food it was found that they did not break pellets into pieces in the process of thickening pollen pellet. Thus, they do not add ferments into them. That is why we have decided to do additional researches with the help of artificial honeycombs. We have used two more methods in our research, except the method of stimulating bees, to store protein food by trampling down a small quantity of pollen pellet (test group). The first method was a single thickening of pollen pellet up to 2/3rd of the height of the cells without processing it (research 1). The second method included the processing of the upper layer by honey (research 2). These ways of getting bee bread by using artificial honeycombs checked the method of stimulating the bees to store protein food by thickening a small amount of freshly harvested pollen pellet in the cells and the process has been repeated 4 times after that. To do this research we have used 3 bee colonies each of which had 5 bees. The honeycombs in the nest were placed in the same area as in the previous research. During this research, we have recorded the number of cells with bee bread and identified the total weight of the pollen pellet we have got after the honeycombs have been in the nests of bee colonies for 2 weeks. The data received during these researches can be found in Table
The effectiveness of different methods of getting bee bread with the help of an artificial honeycomb, n = 5.
the number of cells filled with bee bread, item | the amount of bee bread received from one honeycomb (g) | the number of cells filled with bee bread, item. | the amount of bee bread received from one honeycomb (g) | the number of cells filled with bee bread, item | the amount of bee bread received from one honeycomb (g) | |
4400.2 ±371.06 | 706.6 ±163.56 | 4750.2 ±227.44 | 1135.2 ±159.28 | 4886.4 ±219.30 | 1368.7 ±108.70* | |
3162 – 5139 | 278.19– 1205.06 | 4181 – 5255 | 711.82 – 1618.54 | 4274 – 5357 | 1073.54 – 1687.46 | |
18.86 | 51.76 | 10.71 | 31.38 | 10.04 | 17.76 |
Note: mean – arithmetic mean; SD – standard error of the mean; min, max – minimal and maximal measured values; V – coefficient of variation %; * р <0.05 compared to the test group.
According to the intensity of laying protein food reserves into artificial honeycombs using different ways of stimulating bees to process pollen pellet into bee bread, it has been identified that the bee colonies of the test and research groups 1 and 2 had a different level of activity while doing this jobs. The common thing in the behavior of the bees in all the bee family groups was the thing that while laying bee bread and in the process of finishing its forming, the bees consumed protein food in small amounts. You could see that when the bees have finished processing upper levels of protein food by honey and started eating unripe bee bread the next day. The bees mostly consumed food from the cells of those sections which were located at the bottom of the sides of artificial honeycombs. The bees did not consume bee bread on the central sections of the honeycombs.
After 2 weeks, lots of sections that were located on the peripheral sides of artificial honeycombs had cells with a small amount of bee bread in them, and there were also the ones that appeared to be empty. The intensity of consuming protein food by bee colonies that belong to the same group was different. The bees of some colonies consumed less bee bread and some of them consumed more. The reason for such behavior of bees could not be identified. It is necessary to investigate these processes more thoroughly to solve this problem. It can be inferred that the intensity of consuming protein food depends on different factors. At first, it refers to the age of bee workers, their physiological state, the type and the amount of work that would be done, the quantity of unsealed brood in the nests of bee colonies, etc.
It has been proved that the bees of test and research groups used a different number of cells in artificial honeycombs to process pollen pellet into bee bread depending on the ways of stimulating bees to store protein food. Thus, at the end of the experiment, i.e. 14 days after the protein food reserves have been stored, we have found that 80.1% of the cells on artificial honeycombs were completely or partially filled by bee bread. Co-boundary data (Lim) of this group were between 3162 and 5139 cells. The input of protein food that varied according to the intensity of the process influenced the variation index, which was 18.9% in this group that shows the instability of this index because of the influence of different factors. In general, taking into account the fact that the bees have partially consumed protein food in the cells, single extraction of bee bread in terms of one artificial honeycomb in this group was 706.6 g, with a minimum of 278.2 g and a maximum one of 1205.1 g (Lim), whereas the variation index was 51.76%. It’s necessary to mention that in this group, in which the bee workers did not take part in storing bee bread, protein food was consumed to the biggest extend. This indicates that bee workers use freshly harvested pollen pellet for their own needs at the time when it is actively produced. To decide, which the most attractive food for the bee family is pollen pellet or bee bread, it is necessary to thoroughly investigate the behavior and nutrition of bees.
In the first research group, where a single thickening of the artificial honeycombs section cells with freshly harvested pollen pellet was used, alongside the processing of bee bread, the bees consumed protein food in small amounts. This process was less active than in the test group, though. During the two weeks that were spent on keeping artificial honeycombs of bee colonies 86.4% of section cells were filled with bee bread. If to compare this method with the test group, the bees involved 7.9% cells more for storing bee bread. Because the bees were less active in consuming protein food from section cells, the amount of bee bread we got from one artificial honeycomb was 1135.2 g on average, which is 60.6% more than in the test group. However, if to calculate the number of cells involved and the amount of bee bread received, the difference between the test and the first research group was improbable (
While thickening pollen pellet in the cells of artificial honeycombs with processing food by honey (research 2) the bees worked on storing bee bread more actively. In this group, the percentage of the cells filled with bee bread was almost 90%. Unlike the test group, the bees of the colonies of research group 2 used 11% more cells for storing protein food whereas in research group 1 the percentage was 2.9%. However, alongside this, the consumption of protein food in this group was minimum, unlike in the methods previously used. This influenced the average amount of bee bread received in terms of one artificial honeycomb. Thus, according to the results of the records we got out of each artificial honeycomb, we got 1368.7g in research group 2, which is 93.7% more than in the test group (
By industrially maintaining bee-keeping, bee-keepers get not only honey from the bee colonies but other goods as well. It widens the range of apicultural products in the market and promotes enterprises’ rise in profitability. At the same time, despite the increasing needs for separate kinds of apicultural goods, bee-bread in particular, their overall production level is very slight because of the lack of modern and effective technologies and equipment. So, to get bee-bread, bee-keepers use methods that are based on the destruction of wax combs (
To decrease the pressure of involving the bees in wax building activity, it needs to avoid problems of damaging frames (transporting bee colonies, pumping out honey, etc.), cut costs on buying empty honeycombs, effectively use the biological potential of bee colonies while getting a different kind of goods and improve their quality, prevent affection and spread of diseases, artificial materials for producing honeycombs are widely implemented nowadays. Among them are nest honeycombs, plastic empty honeycombs, plastic honey cells, honeycombs for getting even-aged brood in the artificial raising of queen bees, balls of queenbee cells made of polymer materials, etc. (
The aim and the task of the research were to investigate the ethnology of bees by different ways of stimulating them to form protein food reserves in artificial honeycombs. According to the set aim, the following things had to be done defining the effectiveness of laying bee bread by bees using different ways of preparing containers of artificial honeycombs; research the intensity of forming protein food reserves using different ways of stimulating bees.
The most effective way of stimulating bees to process pollen pellet into bee bread is its single thickening in artificial honeycombs with the following processing of the upper layer of food with honey. Such a method encourages the bees to form bee bread reserves and lessens their activity of consuming protein food from the cells of artificial honeycombs. It is likely that the processing of the thickened pollen pellet with honey oppresses the bees’ necessity to consume protein food from the filled cells and redirects them to other honeycombs of the bee family nest which has areas filled with bee bread reserves.
The publication was created in cooperation with the international network AgroBio
The publication was realized within theproject ITEBIOITMS 26220220115.
Experiments with hives were carried out on hives owned by the author of the publication, Mr Serhii Velychko, who is an officially registered beekeeper in the National Organization of Beekeepers of Ukraine.
Proposed experiment on hives was discussed by the Ethics Committee of the Ministry of Agriculture of Ukraine without comment, because he did not use in the experiments any techniques or synthetic chemicals that caused health problems or death of bees.