ANTIMICROBIAL POTENTIAL OF DIFFERENT MEDICINAL PLANTS AGAINST FOOD INDUSTRY PATHOGENS

Work aimed to investigate the antimicrobial activity of medicinal plants against selected species of food industry pathogens in vitro conditions. The detection of antibacterial properties was examined by the disc diffusion method and the method of the minimum inhibitory concentrations (MIC). The cultivation of microorganisms after the 24 h was performed by disc diffusion method. Petri dishes have grown at 37 °C in which the Mueller Hinton agar and application it to the sterile paper disc impregnated with the extract. The thickness of the resulting inhibition zone was measured with a ruler after completion of the culture. After the preparation of bacteria and extracts of certain concentrations of a subsequently added to wells microplates we use the method of the minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) which was conducted out as the second measurement, and we took the readings absorbance spectrophotometer at 570 nm using the Glomax plate spectrophotometer. We found out, that Equisetum arvense demonstrated the largest zones of inhibition to the tested Grampositive and Gram-negative bacteria. The greatest antimicrobial activity achieved Equisetum arvense, Urtica dioica, and Taraxacum officinale against Salmonella enterica subsp. enterica CCM 3807 and Yersinia enterocolitica CCM 5671. Equisetum arvense and Taraxacum officinale was the most effective against Escherichia coli CCM 2024 and the least effective were Tussilago farfara and Mentha piperita with using the method of minimum inhibitory concentrations.


INTRODUCTION
Salvia officinalis belongs to the largest genus of the family Lamiaceae containing approximately 900 different species worldwide. Some of them can be used as an ingredient in the kitchen, others have been used in the cosmetics industry, and their essential oils are also used as ingredients in various fragrances. Analysis of essential oils of different sage species has shown the most important components, which are made up of substances such as eucalyptol, borneol, thujone, or camphor. Eucalyptol or 1,8-cineol is a natural organic compound. These are cyclic ether and monoterpenoid. Positive properties of killing to leukemia cells have been found in vitro (Baser et al., 1993;Baser et al., 1997;Ahmadi and Mirza, 1999).
The essential oil of sage extract as reported Hammer et al. (1999) and Marino et al. (2001) has inhibitory properties against the following bacteria: Bacillus cereus, Bacillus megatherium, Bacillus subtilis, Aeromonas hydrophila, Aeromonas sobria, Klebsiella oxytoca, Candida albicans, Shigella, Salmonella, and Cryptococcus. Small inhibition zones against Escherichia coli and Staphylococcus aureus have also been observed. The antimicrobial activity of sage in vitro was determined using a minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) and achieved a higher activity against Gram-positive bacteria. The most sensitive of these were S. epidermidis (MIC = 12.5 µg.mL -1 ), B. cereus and B. subtilis (MIC = 25 µg.mL -1 ). In the case of Gram-negative bacteria, only significant activity was demonstrated against E. coli, S. typhi and K. pneumoniae, which showed the lowest MIC values (50 µg.mL -1 ). It was moderately active against P. vulgaris and S. enteritidis (MIC = 100 µg.mL -1 ) (Tenore et al., 2011).
Melissa officinalis belongs to the family Lamiaceae. It is characterized by having 2 to 8 cm soft, slightly hairy leaves, with older, larger leaves having a heart shape (Bown, 2001). Lemon balm as a medicinal plant has proven antimicrobial and antiviral effects. In addition to these effects, anti-fungal Mentha x piperita (Lamiaceae) is generally used for various therapeutic purposes. It comes from Europe and the Middle East, is widespread in Brazilian culture, and can grow in all areas of the country thanks to its modesty. Essential oils show a strong bactericidal effect, in particular against Escherichia coli. When inhaled oil was used concomitantly with multiple drugs in patients with lung tuberculosis, the number of bacilli was demonstrably reduced (Dejani et al., 2014). Mint contains a large amount of fragrant (0.1 -1%) and essential oils. These are mainly monoterpenes, the main components of which are menthol (29 -48%), menthone (20 -31%), menthofuran (6.8%), and their derivatives (isomenthone, neomenthol, menthyl acetate, and pulegone). In menthol and peppermint oil, fungicidal and antiviral activity against Candida albicans, Aspergillus albus, dermatophytic microscopic fungi, and Herpes simplex virus has been demonstrated (Spirling and Daniels, 2001).
Equisetum arvense (Equisetaceae) finds its use in internal use for flushing in bacterial and inflammatory diseases of the urinary tract, kidney sand, gout, and rheumatic diseases; as concomitant treatment in chronic lung diseases, osteoporosis, varicose veins, and immunosuppression. The gilt tea is used to relieve gastric mucosal irritations and heartburn. As the age in the human body increases, the silicon content decreases, so the use of this plant is particularly meaningful in geriatrics (Bühringová, 2010). In determining the antimicrobial activity by the disk diffusion method, the essential oil from the gilt showed strong activity against all strains tested. With the highest inhibition zone, values were found against Gram-negative S. enteritidis (35 mm) and K. pneumoniae (37 mm). The antimicrobial activity of the essential oil of horsetail oil can be attributed to the presence of various substances, in particular phenol, monoterpenes, and thymol. Also, the combination of thymol and 1,8-cineol may result in an important synergistic fungicidal effect (Vatľák et al., 2014).
Taraxacum officinale belongs to the family Asteraceae. It has a beneficial effect on human health due to its antioxidant and antiallergic properties. The root extract can be used as a probiotic in vitro (Yan et al., 2011). A very important part of the plant is the group of sesquiterpene lactones (have anti-inflammatory and anti-cancer effects), phenylpropanoids, polysaccharides and triterpenoids of saponins. The major components of sesquiterpene lactones can often be found in the form of glycosides. These compounds include taraxacine, taraxacerin, dihydrolactucin, ixerin (Schütz et al., 2006a, b). Leaves and dandelion root have beneficial effects in digestion and are considered bitter digestive stimulants. Diuretic effects have also been shown. They probably share a high content of daisies. The root is significant due to mucoprotective, prebiotic, hypoglycemic, and immunostimulatory effects. Tussilago farfara has found its application in the treatment of cough, bronchitis, and asthmatic diseases. Phytochemical studies have shown that the flower contains several types of metabolites, including essential oils, sesquiterpenes, triterpenes, flavonoids, and phenylpropanoids (Li et al., 2013). Studies have shown that coltsfoot has marked pharmacological and antagonistic effects and also has antioxidant and antimicrobial activity (Gao et al., 2008). The antimicrobial activity of the coltsfoot in vitro was determined using the disk diffusion method. The highest antibacterial activity of Tussilago farfara was found on Gram-positive bacteria Lactobacillus rhamnosus (6.67 ±1.53 mm) and lower on yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae (1.67 ±0.58 mm) ( Kačániová et al., 2013).
Urtica dioica (Urticaceae) has been known in Europe and has been used as a medicinal plant for over 2000 years. The leaf and the root are used for these purposes. Leaf extract has been found to be of use in the symptomatic treatment of arthritis, arthrosis, and rheumatic problems, as well as a diuretic for inflammatory diseases of the urinary tract and bladder and overall detoxification of the body. The whole part of the plant can be used for various purposes such as food, feed, medicines, cosmetics, biodynamic agriculture, and textile production (Bodros and Baley, 2008). Clinical studies have shown that the juice obtained from this plant has a diuretic effect in patients suffering from congestive heart failure. It helps in digestion and promotes milk production of nursing mothers. It provides short-term pain relief and is therefore also used to treat rheumatism. It has also been used in the treatment of arthritis, urinary tract diseases, respiratory diseases, body cleansing, etc. It contains silicic acid, which has diuretic effects, chlorophyll with anti-inflammatory and disinfectant properties, anti-bleeding tannins, and glucokinins, which lower blood sugar (Bisht et al., 2012).

Scientific hypothesis
The different antimicrobial effect exists among analysed medicinal plants for individual food industries pathogens. Antimicrobial activity to pathogenic bacterial strains of food industries is variable for individual medicinal plant species.

Plant material
Extracts from 7 different medical plants, obtained from Nitra region, were used to demonstrate antimicrobial activity against selected pathogens. The plant parts such as stems, leaves, and flowers were left to dry in a well-aired dark place at room temperature. Ten grams of dried plants were crushed and extracted with 100 mL of ethanol. Extracts from the plants were leached for two weeks at room temperature and subsequently, ethanol was evaporated by vacuum evaporator (Stuart RE300DB, UK). The samples were stored in the freezer at -20 °C.

Tested strains of microorganisms
For determination of antimicrobial activity 5 bacterial species were purchased from Czech Collection of Microorganisms (CCM, Brno). Three of selected strains were Gram-negative (Salmonella enterica subsp. enterica CCM 3807, Yersinia enterocolitica CCM 5671, Escherichia coli CCM 2024) and two strains were Grampositive (Staphylococcus aureus subsp. aureus CCM 2461, Listeria monocytogenes CCM 4699).

Disk diffusion method
Five bacterial cultures grown overnight at 37 °C Muller Hinton broth (MBH) were diluted with distilled water to the turbidity 0.5 according to McFarland standard (measured on densilameter). Petri dishes with Mueller-Hinton agar were covered by 100 µL of cell culture with use of L-shaped cell spreader. Petri dishes were dried in a thermostat.
For each bacteria strain were prepared 9 discs with 6 mm diameter (7 discs with medicinal plants, 1 positive control and 1 negative control). Discs were soaked in plant extracts with use of sterile tweezers and afterwards were placed on Petri dishes with cell cultures. Disc with distilled water was used as negative control and disc with antibiotic (gentamycin for G + bacteria and tobramycine for Gbacteria) was used as positive control.
Prepared samples were incubated for 24 hours at 37 °C. After incubation period, diameter of each inhibition zone was measured in 3 directions, and average size of inhibition zone was calculated.

Minimum inhibitory concentration
The microdilution method is carried out in 0.5 mL microtiter plates. There was A 96 well microtiter plate used in the assay. A stock solution of various concentrations of the medicinal plant is prepared for each well of the plate. There are 12 wells in row A -H into which we pipet 0.5 mL of Mueller -Hinton broth culture medium. The plant extract was pipetted in the next step from row A -H of the first column. Plant extracts were prepared according to the desired concentration and diluted with dimethylsulfoxide. The extracts were pipetted with the given microorganisms with a concentration of 0.5 McFarland. Using an automatic eight-channel pipette with a preset value of 100 μL, the suspension from the wells of the first column was transferred to the second column. We repeated the procedure until the concentration was reduced in this way. The whole plate concentration was measured with an absorbance spectrophotometer at 570 nm using the Glomax plate spectrophotometer. The cultivation proceeded from 16 to 18 hours. After its completion, we again measured concentration throughout the plate, and from the pre-and post-cultivation readings, we calculated the differences in absorbance. It can be stated that the minimum inhibitory concentration and its value had the lowest extract concentration at which inhibitory bacterial growth was detectable.

Statistical analysis
Mean and standard deviation with Excel were used for the disk diffusion method. Using obtained absorbance before and after the analysis, we were able to express the differences in absorbance between the measurements as a set of binary values. These values were assigned to exact concentrations. The following formula was created for this specific experiment: value 1 (inhibitory effect) was assigned to absorbance values lower than 0.05, while value 0 (no effect or stimulant effect) was assigned to absorbance values higher than 0.05. For this statistical evaluation probit analysis in Statgraphics software was used for minimal inhibitory concentration.  (Table 1) indicated that E. coli, S. enterica, and Y. enterocolitica were more sensitive to extracts from selected medicinal plants than L. monocytogenes and S. aureus.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The most significant antimicrobial effect was observed at Equisetum arvense that exhibited the largest inhibition zones against all bacteria. Considerable results were observed at Y. enterocolitica, E. coli, and S. enterica with sizes of inhibitory zones 15.33 ±0.58 mm, 14.67 ±0.58 mm and 14.33 ±0.58 mm respectively. Also, L. monocytogenes and S. aureus showed the highest sensitivity against Equisetum arvense.
Tussilago farfara and Melissa officinalis also showed significantly larger inhibition zones, while Salvia officinalis and Mentha piperita seemed to be the least effective. Overall this test indicated that Gram-negative bacteria are more susceptible to the antimicrobial activity of medicinal plant extracts.
According to the minimum inhibitory concentration test (Table 2), slight variations in antimicrobial sensitivity were observed against the disk diffusion method. However, the same trend with higher sensitivity against plant extract was observed in a group of Gram-negative bacteria E. coli, S. enterica, and Y. enterocolitica. Also, the most conspicuous growth inhibition was caused by Equisetum arvense extract with the lowest detected inhibitory concentration at MIC 50: 9.59 μg.mL -1 and MIC 90: 10.20 μg.mL -1 for Gram-negative bacteria and MIC50: 12.8 μg.mL -1 and MIC90: 14.29 μg.mL -1 for Grampositive bacteria (L. monocytogenes and S. aureus). This observation corresponded with the previous test.
In addition, according to MIC test, also Taraxacum officinale and Urtica dioica extracts achieved comparable values of cell growth inhibition as Equisetum arvense. On the other side, Mentha piperita and Tussilago farfara seemed to be the least effective.
From the perspective of bacteria, the most sensitive to the antimicrobial activity of all tested medicinal plant extracts was S. enterica followed by another Gram-positive bacteria E. coli and Y. enterocolitica that were slightly more resistant especially to plant extracts with inferior antimicrobial effectivity. A great interest in biologically active substances of plant origin increased in recent years. Many of these substances demonstrated an antimicrobial effect (Essawi and Srour, 2000). Kačániová  According to two statistical processing of disc diffusion method Hleba et al. (2013) indicated that the Tussilago farfara extract reached size of inhibition zones 16.7 ±3.65 mm for ampicillin and chloramphenicol resistant Escherichia coli isolated from conventional cow breeding and 8.3 ±1.41 mm for antibiotics when we consider that Escherichia coli has been isolated from organic mare breeding. In contrast, the methanolic extract of Aesculus hippocastanum (diameter of inhibition zones 9 ±1.88 mm) had the least antimicrobial effect.  show that oil from Achillea millefolium extract may be an alternative to antibiotics in the control of some Gram-positive and Gram-negative pathogens. The antibacterial activity of some Agrimonia eupatoria extracts against pathogenic bacteria (Staphylococcus aureus, Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Escherichia coli) and their action on wound healing in rats has been confirmed. The presence of certain active substances in both aqueous and ethanol extracts has also been demonstrated, indicating that Agrimonia eupatoria may exhibit antimicrobial activity. The results of this study showed that the ethanol extract was more effective at inhibiting the bacteria tested than the aqueous extract. Pseudomonas aeruginosa was most resistant to the action of ethanol extract, while Escherichia coli with the highest zone of inhibition of 20 mm was the most susceptible. There was moderate activity against Staphylococcus aureus with 15 mm inhibition zone after application of ethanol extract (10 mg.mL -1 ).
With Antimicrobial activity (expressed as μg.mL -1 ) from four ethanolic extracts of Achillea millefolium, Agrimonia eupatoria, Melissa officinalis and Tilia platyphyllos against various strains of Gram-positive and Gramnegative bacteria. It was found that more susceptible to Agrimonia eupatoria extract with a MIC50 value of 0.80 μg.mL -1 of Bacillus cereus, Lactobacillus brevis was less susceptible to Agrimonia eupatoria with a MIC50 value of 1.48 μg.mL -1 .
The bacteria Lactobacillus hilgardii, Enterococcus faecalis, and Escherichia coli were less sensitive to Agrimonia eupatoria extract and the values were higher MIC50 (MIC 2.56 -17.06 μg.mL -1 ). Lactobacillus brevis was more sensitive to Melissa officinalis with a MIC50 of 6.39 μg.mL -1 . In addition, the activity of Achillea millefolium against Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria was contrary to previous reports that antibacterial activity was limited to Gram-positive bacteria from medicinal herbs (Ghaima, 2013).

CONCLUSION
Medicinal plants have been used for treating various diseases due to their beneficial effects and sources of bioactive secondary metabolites for long times. In recent years, research has been increasingly investigating their antimicrobial activity against various pathogens. The emphasis should be placed on further research and monitoring of their effects. The plants that we used in the research showed an antimicrobial effect against Grampositive and Gram-negative bacteria.